One of the biggest questions that parents with college-bound children puzzle with is if their child has a chance for financial aid.
This is more confusing than you might think because at some schools a family could qualify for need-based aid if they make $200,000 a year and at another school, the ceiling for aid could be $70,000.
The first step that you should take when grappling with this issue is to obtain your Expected Family Contribution. You should do this before seriously exploring your teenager’s college options.
10 EFC Tips
Here is a summary of what you should know about this important figure:
An Expected Family Contribution is a dollar figure that represents what financial aid formulas believe a family should be able to pay for one year of a child’s college education.
The EFC for the average American household with an AGI of $50,000 will usually range from $3,000 to $4,000. There is no cap on EFCs so some very wealthy families will have EFCs that exceed the cost of an expensive private university.
It’s best to get a ballpark idea of what a family’s EFC will be as early as a child’s freshman year in high school. Obtaining a preliminary EFC will give parents a rough idea of the minimum amount that they would be expected to pay for college.
Families with household incomes of $60,000 to $80,000 and above typically find that they do not qualify for need-based aid at state universities, but they may qualify for need-based aid at private schools.
Determining if a student would be eligible for need-based aid requires subtracting the EFC from a school’s cost of attendance.
- $60,000 Cost of attendance
- $25,000 EFC
- $35,000 financial aid eligibility
Families, who discover that they have a high EFC and aren’t eligible for need-based financial aid, should look for schools that provide merit scholarships that are given regardless of need. Most schools fall into this category.
If an EFC is modest, families should search for schools that provide excellent need-based assistance. Far fewer schools fit into this category.
Families will usually have to pay more for college than their EFC indicates they can afford because most schools do not meet 100% of a student’s demonstrated financial need. Consequently, it’s important to identify the most generous colleges that would consider a child an attractive candidate.
Parents can obtain their Expected Family Contribution by using the College Board’s EFC Calculator. Here is what the calculator home page looks like:
You will need to use figures from your income tax return and your latest non-retirement investment account statements including checking and savings accounts and any accounts and income that your child has.
With this calculator, parents will want to obtain their EFC using the federal and institutional formulas. The calculator will produce one EFC using the federal methodology that is linked to the Free Application for Federal Student Aid.
The calculator will also produce an EFC using the institutional methodology, which is linked to the CSS/Financial Aid PROFILE. The vast majority of private and public colleges and universities only use the FAFSA while 229 mostly private, selective schools also use the PROFILE.
After completing the FAFSA, a student will receive his/her official federal EFC via an electronic document called the Student Aid Report. The SAR will include the family’s EFC near the top of the report and also provide all the information that the family included on the FAFSA. Parents should check for accuracy.
PROFILE filers will not receive an EFC from the College Board, which owns and operates this financial aid application. Institutions that use the PROFILE customize their aid applications by choosing from hundreds of different questions so you will end up with a different EFC for each school. Parents should ask each PROFILE school for their EFC if the institutions do not include this important dollar figure on their children’s financial aid awards.
Unfortunately, many schools don’t include a family’s EFC on their financial aid awards. Some institutions suggest that including the EFC on their aid letters will confuse families. More likely, schools don’t want to share EFC figures with families because they can then determine if the package is stingy.
Once a family has their EFC and the financial aid package, compare the EFC with what a school is offering. Let’s say that the cost of a school after deducting institutional grants is $39,000 and the EFC is $28,000. That means there is an $11,000 gap between what the EFC suggests that a family can pay and what the school wants to charge your client. Based on this knowledge, a family can appeal the award.
Plug new numbers into the EFC calculator if a family’s financial situation changes due to such things as a divorce, separation, death, disability, job loss or the care of an elderly parent.
If you’d like to dive much deeper into how to cut the cost of college, please sign up to be notified when I have more information about the next launch of my popular online course – The College Cost Lab.
I’ll be relaunching my online course in mid-to-late February 2018.
Enjoyed the Larry Mantle show today and wanted to mention something no one talks about which is the fact that a college student (I have 1 sophomore) can pay as much as $300 for one book per semester. These additional costs are rarely mentioned and after much research we ended up at an out-of-state school that provided 100% tuition coverage rather than a meagerly reduced rate at an in-state 4-year college.
For parents with fluctuating incomes: Last year we qualified for a subsidized loan and counted on this money this year, but with the FAFSA showing our income had improved slightly, we had to pay for a Parent Plus Loan which makes a huge difference.
There is so much to learn about this whole process!
I am glad you heard the show on the LA NPR station. You are right about textbooks, which are a rip off. I am glad to hear that your child got a full tuition scholarship at an out-of-state school. Most people don’t get that deal.
With the changes in the 2017-18 FAFSA timing, will parents need to upload 2016 tax information later in 2017 when available, or will we link to completed 2015 return only?
When applying for the 2017-2018 school year, you will only use the 2015 taxes.
You would use the 2016 taxes for the 2018-2019 school year.
Hi, Lynn –
Another terrific post, and I’d like to share it on the college information Facebook page I administer for La Jolla High. However, it looks like something (a graphic or additional information) might be missing from item #4 where you refer to “This affluent family’s EFC…” and “In this scenario…” Am I missing something?
As always, thank you for such valuable information!
I fixed the problem! Thanks for the alert! Please use the post at La Jolla High!
I’m an IEC in Portland, OR. and am doing a presentation at the Multnomah Athletic Club here on Aug. 17. It is a fully enrolled at 120 attendees, and Financial Aid is a “hot topic” with this group.
Do you do private seminars, and would something like this appeal to you? I’ll put out some “feelers”in my presentation.
This is a fairly affluent group who would be willing to pay for advice.
Lynn: I just filled out the FASFA what a daunting task even when you import your taxes directly into it. I still didn’t find which line you enter in your savings account dollar amount or your 401K money.
I wanted to let you know that the FAFSA for the 2017-2018 school year won’t be available until Oct. 1. If you are filling it out now it would be for the 2016-2017 school year. Just FYI.
Does the FAFSA take into account cost of living when determining the EFC? For example, $100k is not going to go nearly as far in Boston as opposed to Boise.
The FAFSA does not consider where a student lives when determining an EFC, but the CSS/Financial Aid PROFILE does.
So if the FAFSA doesn’t do this, and the school doesn’t require the CSS profile, then the school should be looking at cost of living when determining aid, which my son’s school (UNH) apparently doesn’t do as they said the FAFSA takes care of it. Seems like a big problem. If they aren’t taking cost of living into account, they aren’t comparing apples to apples.